Oh what could have been – A cautionary tale!

Oh what could have been – A cautionary tale!
A few days have now passed. The result, and its disappointments, have finally sunk in. It wasn’t to be. It seems easy enough to say now, but the Bernabeu was just not meant to house the men from Catalunya. There we go. We move on.
Yet there are many lessons we can learn from our loss against Inter Milan, not least of all just how lucky we were that a certain Portuguese was never given the reigns of our club.

If stories are to be believed, Mourinho was a matter of moments away from taking control at Barca before some bright spark (Johan Cruyff perhaps?!) decided to take a chance on the young buck who was working miracles with Barca B. Yes he was untried, yes he was young and inexperienced, but he was Barca through and through. From style to substance Josep Guardiola was, and is, a man with Barca in his blood.

Mourinho is not. He may be succesful. He may be a winner. He may even be a ‘real character’. But he is not Barca. In fact, he is perfectly and unashamedly Madrid: arrogant, self-satisfied, more obsessed with press coverage and headlines than beautiful football or home-grown talent.

He sums up what Real Madrid want (and, if rumours are to be believed, will get this summer) – success at any cost. An ‘all eyes on me’ approach to football that is not only unhealthy, it is also irredeemably dull. Football should be poetry in motion. It should be thought and deed aligning to create something bigger than ourselves. Something that brings joy to millions, inspires and excites. This is not something Jose understands.

Imagine if you will a pock-marked, desert scene. On it stand two sets of swaying goal-posts, seperated by a crudely outlined football pitch. Upon that pitch play a number of children, kicking an old ball from one end to another. One set of children play with smiles on their faces, with freedom and enjoyment. They try tricks and audacious passes, over-head kicks and mazey runs. They dream of Messi, Ronaldinho, Rivaldo, even Gerard Pique.

The other set of kids just want to win, at any cost. They line up as if going into battle, setting up ranks within their own half. They feel no affection for the ball, only affection for the end result. They hack the ‘happy’ kids to the ground and celebrate when their inspired moments don’t quite come off. They waste time and play-act, forever rolling on the floor. They dream of someday playing for Mourinho.

Of course their dream may well come true. Jose loves a good signing or two, doesn’t he. In fact, Mourinho likes to sign players so much that on Wednesday night, not one Italian appeared on the pitch whatsoever for Inter. A proud moment indeed for all Italians.

He did the same at Chelsea, where a blank cheque from Mr. Abramovic enabled bodies to arrive in such great numbers, that only John Terry and Frank Lampard were truly able to hold down permanent places within the team. Even the most creative and under-valued of English talents, Joe Cole, struggled to find a constant place within Jose’s system.

Now of course there is a need for signing fresh blood and looking abroad for great talent, but that need becomes a neccesity where Mourinho is involved. He doesn’t care for heritage or culture. He cares about himself and the legend he will be when he leaves the club. All of this is fine. Football has always had an element of egotism running through its very weak moral core, but Mourinho takes it to the extreme.

Only at Porto, where funds were not so forthcoming, did the ‘special one’ play with anything like a homegrown squad. But even then, the tactics were so stilted and nulifying that anyone who truly appreciates the art of football, and the magic it can create, was bored senseless by the approach. Yes they had some great players (most notably Deco,Helder Postiga and Ricardo Carvalho), but what they were asked to do was demeaning and dull. Surely only psychologists and politicians can truly love a Jose Mourinho team.

Perhaps this is where Real Madrid come into the equation. They have seen what Mourinho can do, and any doubts they may have once had have surely now vanished. Sure, he may take some of the limelight away from the players, and maybe even worse, Florentino Perez, but if he can stop all the talk about this great generation that’s flowering up in Catalunya, then job done. Madrid will be the talk of the town once again.

They know Mourinho will attract the world’s eye even more than the signing CR9, Kaka, or the re-animated corpse of George Best. They know he will bring results and trophies. He will bring glory, and outrage, and constant constant discussion, but he will not bring pure football. He will not ‘give the kids a chance’ or resurect the youth system the way Wenger or Ferguson have done at their respective clubs.

Now it must be said Mourinho is not all bad. He does have a keen eye for a great player: Cech, Robben, Sneijder, Eto’o,Diego Milito. He also has a way of protecting and supporting his players that creates an ‘us against them’ mentality that proves priceless throughout the course of a season. He is charismatic and, at moments, even charming and funny. But this persona and obsession with playing the publicity game hides a very simple fact that Jose doesn’t want us to notice; the style of football he brings with him is totally graceless and devoid of all charm.

We accept this may sound angry and bitter, and that’s because it is. Some of us still believe in beauty Jose! Some of us still believe in magic, and creativity, and inspiration. Some of us still believe in, and care about, football, and that is why the hearts of those who love Barca hope you never darken the door of our manager’s office.

In Catalunya, the ‘Special One’ goes by the name of FC Barcelona. The FC stands for Football Club, not anti-football club, and as such we will continue in our quest to win trophies with flair and creativity on the pitch, grace and honour off of it. Yes it takes courage and belief to do so, and yes we may stumble sometimes, we may even occasionally be beaten, but with a team full of young, home-grown, talented and intelligent footballers such as we have today, then anything is possible, as the sextet just serves to prove.

We are Barca! We are Football!

subscribe to comments RSS

Comments are closed

  1. changara says:

    Great!
    Quote of the week for me…''some people think Real Madrid not being able to put up a fight against Barca on two occasions in the season but still pushing them for the title to the last week is a testament to Real Madrid’s greatness. I differ. I think it is sad that they have been reduced from the lions, hunters, that they once were to mere scavengers, vultures, waiting, week in week out for the lion to die for them to have a meal''.

  2. FINiesta says:

    Simply the best article which I have ever read in this site – so far, I hope =)

    Thank you! Thank you!

  3. harshawardhan says:

    Beautiful!
    I am at a loss of words..
    Thankyou for this Spencer..

    • barca says:

      simply outstanding…. totally agree with every word…. barca is barca … no one comes close to barca we r the best…. we r the last hope of football in this lost football world

  4. [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by mdavd and Monica Ramirez, totalBarça. totalBarça said: Oh what could have been – A cautionary tale! – http://bit.ly/clmqFQ [...]

  5. Ashjay says:

    Nice one, and in total agreement. Thanks for this article!

  6. awesome article! beautifully written..

  7. Teddy says:

    Whenever I see such a deep understanding of what Barca is from a fan that may not even be a Catalan, I always love the thought of loving Barca. Barca is not essentially about losing or winning. It is beyond that. Way beyond that. It is about defending what is right and what ought to be right; it is defending about beauty and truth. Ever wondered why "More than a club" is more than a motto?It's because everything Barca symbolizes is everything beyond what it is taken for granted but what necessarily is not right. Modern football is about big players and the art of defending (if there is such an art); Barca defies this. If there is poetry in football, I know no other name but Barca. Modern football is about corporate profit maximization at all cost. Barca defies this. It recognizes there are more important things in life–humanity, fairness, comradeship and balance. Yes I am talking about the FCB Foundation, UNICEF, UNHCR, XICS, JCS, UNESCO and others, but in a more contextual sense. Do not forget that Barca never wore a shirt sponsorship until recently. Until then I thought they were great. After UNICEF, I realized that Barca are not great; they are sacred. Until UNICEF, they stood up for their ideals (and stood up well); after UNICEF they stood up for others, probably for the most vulnerable groups of our planet–children. Modern football is also about one man ownership. Barca defies this. Throughout it's history, Barca has fought for titles on the field, and even more so for democracy off it. It fought fascism, segregation and inequality. It is THE club of the people. They name their leader, and only they can un-name it. So that's why when I wear my blue and red colours and walk around, I know I am subscribing to an ideal larger than myself. That's why I say "More than a club" is more than a motto.

    (Anyway, I didn't intend to write this all. You inspired me Spencer. Thanks. Keep on doing the good job. Thanks.Back to my assignment. Visca Barca!

    • xaviniesta says:

      well said teddy, agree 100%. barca truly represents and its not just in football but also outside of it. makes you feel really proud of being a cule.

      thanks for article spence.

  8. harshawardhan says:

    nicely said!

  9. Rahul says:

    So, when on the verge of not winning as much as last year, the inner beauty has to be elaborated. Alright.

  10. HieiFCB says:

    Thumbs up :D

    You just sums it up so greatly.

  11. HieiFCB says:

    Great article Spencer!!!

  12. Jassim says:

    They make us feel better dont they?
    Awesome post !

  13. n1rvana says:

    Nice article! Thanks for the sweet poetry.

  14. Cule Bahrain says:

    Jose is a great manager with Charisma. He is a leader and does exactly as you said "creates an us vs them mentality". And he can get the most out of any player defensively. But he is definitely NOT Barca thank God for Pep Visca el Barca

  15. silvia says:

    to me, barca are always handicapped . Barca to me play 10 versus 11 men team .we do not have a forward that suit our style.the right choice should be villa, rooney or Torres.

  16. Leo10 says:

    Lineup with Mourinho?

    Valdes
    Zambrotta – Puyol – Marquez – Abidal
    Xavi – Essien – Lampard
    Messi
    Drogba – Eto'o

    Any other opinions? Not sure on that RB position

  17. Marc4barca says:

    True barca fan right here, great read teddy.

  18. FCB_fR3aK says:

    LOL. Actually move Messi to Right Wing-Back in place of Zambrotta and put Ballack in there.. Then Etoo drops back to left back for most of the game… Ultimate strategy… Valdes (or Cech maybe) Kicks the ball all the way to Drogba for goals. Works like a charm..

  19. n1rvana says:

    ……..

  20. n1rvana says:

    …….

  21. JSK_87 says:

    mourinho did'nt sign cech or robben….ranieri did. snieder, eto and milito were always gunno be good. Muntari onnthe other hand…..cracking buy haha

  22. Marc4barca says:

    Great Article!!! I hate what football has become with all this bankruptcy, diving, 10 men behind the ball, play acting to kill time, fans cheering opponents, corrupt referee and politics.

    I know Barcelona aren't a perfect club, no club is but this definitely is the closet to it. i applaud all fans who chose barca for the right reason

  23. jay says:

    oh come on as if barca players wouldn't dive and play-act, doing anything to win.
    just because their style is more pleasing to the eye doesn't make them saints.
    I'm a barca fan and appreciate their philosophy, but that doesn't mean i cant also appreciate mourinhos teams.
    Different of course. appealing in a different way, but impressive none of the less.

    You cant deny that is was incredible impressive how inter nullified barca over the course of two legs.

  24. Amit says:

    Remember guys when we say Barca4life, we mean it.

  25. Nico says:

    Mourinho no matter what you do you'll never be Barca's coach! NEVER EVER!
    Thieves aren't welcome in Catalunya!

  26. diego says:

    Very nice article

  27. -Mayotte- says:

    Greta great articel…A+ :*
    Not just thief…LIAR too …:@ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dV8mC482tFs

  28. tonyspeed says:

    barca, you treat your old players like garbage. you are a rubbish team. football was not meant to be anything in particular. each manager has his own style. that is what makes football exciting. barcelona you think too much of yourself. that's why you burnt up. you thought you were invincible. you tried to fly too close to the sun and your wings were clipped. barcelona. you are the devil destroyed in mid-flight. down with barcelona.

  29. kamikaze kontiki says:

    Very well written piece. Great read !

  30. Jason says:

    LOL! What a sore loser. Grow up you idiot! Personally, how someone supports antifootball is beyond me. Go back to you're antifootball, one goal, and defend with 10 men to keep the one goal. BORING!

  31. Salcini says:

    Great article and I totally agree about Mourinho not being Barca-material. But to say that he is Real Madrid-material is pretty harsh. Keep in mind that they actually fired Fabio Capello because he didn't make the team play beautiful enough. His personality with the arrogance and everything like that would be well-fitted with them though, but the playing style I am not so sure about.

    VISCA BARCA!

  32. GueRakun says:

    Thanks Spencer.. made my day..

  33. We are Barca! We are Football!
    This is what i have been saying from the last year.
    All "new" Barca fans are filled with arrogancy and knows nothing about football.
    Most of you saying great article, especially the one who wrote the article, are arrogant pricks.
    I will ask you a simple question, since when do u support Barca? Three four year … When we started winning? Have you been here during the figo – rivaldo Era? when we struggled to win with the same style? Have you been here when puyol was just starting?
    How many of you did actually see guardiola playing for us? This article is just full of arrogance.

    We are Cule but we aren't the football, football can't be sum to our way of playing it .
    We love Barca because we love this way which has never change, which has bring us pain and pleasure, success and faillure. This is the only way we enjoy soccer.
    BUT THIS IS NOT THE ONLY WAY SOCCER SHOULD BE PLAYED !!!

    Please learn what it means to be humble, learn that football is about diversity.
    If everyone was playing as us, football will be boring.
    I agree with one thing, Guardiola is the best suit for barca's style, but his arrogancy doesn't suit our spirit.
    Riijkaard is an example of Barca soul and Spirit or Koeman….

    You don't know what is football , and none of you will be with us when we will start sucking with the same style. And that will definitely happen one day, when this generation will be gone. Learn to be humble and respect the Other.
    And please don't compare Mourinho and Guardiola, it's an insult to Mourinho talent and wisdom.

    Visca Barca and Visca the Real Cule, those who count more than five years of affiliation

  34. 0marX says:

    Great article! :)

  35. dizzies says:

    Look at thishttp://www.manutd24.com/rivals-watch/fc-barcelona… , got it from an old traford's fan site . This is what happen when cules are so blind, the other side got the materials to laugh at us.