Barcelona-based Media Jump Into Madrid’s Sandbox

Barcelona-based Media Jump Into Madrid’s Sandbox

Rugby players love to taunt us that “Football is a gentleman’s game played by hooligans.” The same sentiment applies to professional sports journalists in Spain.

For weeks now, madridista writers have accused FC Barcelona and Spanish Football Federation president Angel Maria Villar of conspiring against Madrid, against football, against puppies and against God. There is no evidence offered beyond the standard second-guessing of referees (a tradition as old as refereeing itself). As the drumbeat of conspiracy has crescendoed, and the headlines have turned ever more shrill, culés have begun to feel they must respond. And so we see a disappointing 2-2 result blamed on a harsh decision– the harsh decision blamed on the madridista writers– and the whole ugly package wrapped up in a bow of “I know you are but what am I?” (that is to say, Real Madrid’s comeback victory over Sevilla is chalked up to officiating mistakes).

It’s hard to blame the writers and publishers of partisan football rags. After all, theirs used to be an indispensable and almost honorable function. Before massive television contracts and widely-available internet streams, when only a tiny portion of the fan base could sit in the stand and watch the home side scrap its way through 90 minutes, sportswriters were our only conduit for information on our teams.

The internet has democratized the fan experience. Arguments about Busquets’ play in midfield or Ibra’s recent form can stretch round the globe without any of us leaving our keyboards. We don’t need sportswriters as much anymore, but they certainly need us. They count on our attention to sell advertising. Football journalism, in many places, is a simple bottom-line business. And nothing catches the attention of the Spanish football fan like a good chunk of morbo.

“Morbo” is a tough word to translate to english. Most dictionaries fail to grasp the whole of the concept, and Phil Ball needed a couple hundred pages to explain the concept in his wonderful book of the same name. Basically, it is the combination of emotion (outrage and passion work best) with a sense of scandal and an opportunity for vengeance. Sport is the perfect outlet for morbo, as many sociologists have observed over the years.

“It is good that sports are so important. They…play a role of relieving pressures in human beings which once had no other outlets but wars, Bedlams, and public hangings.” — Robert Nesbit, American Sociologist

In a country with so many distinct nationalisms, football sides are vessels for regional pride and results matter to us far more than they should (or so my girlfriends have always told me, while shaking their heads and packing their suitcases). The tension between Madrid and Barcelona is too old, too broad, too serious to fit onto a football pitch– and yet it does, at least twice a season. Recently, it’s even been crammed into the front pages of sport magazines.

“Villarato!” and conspiracy are the watchwords for Marca and AS. Their childish disease has has proved catching. As Barca fans, we may be inclined to nod along when El Mundo Deportivo decries Barca’s “persecution” in the press, and blames Marca for harsh decisions by the officials, but it is no less shrill or embarrassing when it comes from “our” side of this silly standoff.

Instead of serious tactical discussions, writers are left kicking sand back and forth across Iberia. “Pedro was offside (and a half-baked graphic to prove it!)” cries Madrid; “You’re influencing the refs! And Sevilla should’ve won because you didn’t earn the corner that led to 2-2!” shrieks Barcelona. “We’d be in first if you weren’t cheaters!” whines the capital; and on, and on.

Bad decisions, missed fouls, successful dives are all part of our beloved sport, and ever shall be. I guess the adult thing to do is to ignore it. It’s too bad Barcelona’s newspapers have decided to fight fire with fire. I for one will not feed this beast any more, with mouseclicks or words. I refuse to pay attention to this nonsense again until someone produces evidence of corruption, or invents a robot that will never get a call wrong.

by ock19

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

subscribe to comments RSS

There are 17 comments for this post

  1. Interesting piece. I agree, though I know I've fallen victim to thinking the refs are influenced by this, myself, as I said to you earlier. I like the line about girlfriends…it makes the ones who are willing to put up with us that much more special!

  2. Moe says:

    of course we shud fight it … u think i will applause madrid if they win a title .. i will never do that to them …

  3. Madrid is committing "a perfect crime" and never leaves any evidence behind!!!I agree with much of what you said,but I couldn't hold myself from suspecting the referees and Madrid's credibility and fair play !!!There must be a little something

  4. kamikaze kontiki says:

    Wonderfully written article !!!

  5. Ryuuzaki says:

    true words

  6. harshawardhan says:

    great article.. what you suggest to be done is righ and proper but very diifficult to actually do.. AS and Marca come up with such stupidity that would boil the blood of any cule.. its difficult not to retaliate.. but we should all try not to mind any bull.s.hit that these dailies come up with and just watch the beautiful game played by our beautiful team.

  7. Jay says:

    See I would agree with you except lately it's been too much of a coincidence than to just overlook it and blame it on team play. Ever since these stories have come out from Marca, Pique, Marquez, Ibra, Pep, have been red carded. To me this only stems from one source, the controversial sending off of CR9 when they used messi's push as evidence. Ever since then everyone has scrutinized us, and it shows by jeopardizing us in games. So to fight fire with fire is right, to ensure a fair judgment, to let refs know that we will complain if they fuck up and that we want a decision not influenced by Madrid. Honestly to me they want to win at all cost just because they spent 250mil and that's not right. That's why unlike you I have the balls to say FUCK THEM! fire with fire it is.

    • ock19 says:

      Dude, I respect what you're saying. And like I tried to suggest in the post, I understand _why_ Sport/EMD/etc are responding this way. It's got nothing to do with "having the balls." I'd rather think about tactical stuff and transfers and look ahead than sweat the referees– we can't undo what's done. I'm not blaming the reds on our guys, I think they were bad decisions…and bad decisions happen. To every team, at different times, sometimes in weird patterns– but they happen.

      And listen, I hate RM plenty, but there's no salary cap in our sport so how can we be pissed about what they spend? I'm much more worried about, say, the rumors we'll lose Bojan (pretty high ceiling, young kid) for Ribery (talented, but doesn't give us anything we really _need_ and don't already have).

  8. kamikaze kontiki says:

    Cant see my earlier comment, so I will write it again. Wonderfully written article !

  9. [...] Read the original: Barcelona-based Media Jump Into Madrid's Sandbox | totalBarça [...]

  10. Stevenson says:

    Great article. Personally I don't think we should ignore the reporting about referees, but we should take articles on both sides with a grain of salt and recognize the bias that each publication might have. I think its an interesting dimension of the competition between Barcelona and Madrid to see how these battles rage in the press. The whole Villarato campaign is basically an invention of the publisher of As, but its hard to imagine that Liga referees are not influenced by claims like this.

    I also agree that human, imperfect refs are a part of the game we all love. But recent events in Italy and Germany indicate that tampering with match officials is not beyond the realm of possibility.

    • ock19 says:

      Well said, Stevenson. Actual cheating/bribery is always a possibility in these things– so is an official with a gambling problem (look at the NBA!) looking to throw a result.

      What bugs me is that Marca plays the same crap every season, at roughly this point in the campaign, just to needle us….and then we inevitably react to it. I for one learned in grade school that bullies pick on the kids who react the most. Walk tall and carry a big stick, I say– or in this case, Mind your own dressing room & carry the best roster on the planet.

  11. SJP says:

    Excellent article, exactly how i WANT to think, except its getting too much, maybe it will all even out now, in a practical if not paper sense, but very well said, and i will try hard to follow.

  12. Pablo says:

    Great article. I agree 100%

  13. matyrze says:

    Good article.

    I think Madrid press are doing some sort of vengeance for those Blancos, as Catalans have thrown similar accuses in the past, particularly during Franco's era.

  14. [...] Barcelona-based Media Jump Into Madrid's Sandbox | totalBarça Malaysia's exports jump 37 percent in January « dr dzul's weblogNewNet News – China WindPower Group reports profit jump, sets out …Bowing to the Future: Get the Jump on the FutureSen. Collins: energy bill could jump start Senate | SeacoastOnline.comVonn's Olympics End With Slalom Mistake, 2 Medals – Sports News …Jaipur colour manufacturers charged up for Holi festivalC.N Blue, “Jung YongHwa never made a mistake on Music Bank” « K BitesA mistake behind her, Vonn hopes shin can hold out – Olympic …ModLife » Blog Archive » Let Women Jump!Swansea police seek toddler in silver car with Minn. plates … View the Contact Powered by Staff [...]

  15. @samm121 says:

    "Villarato" definitely is madrid's conspiracy. they put pressure on refereeing. only we can do is no arguing. ignore? no we can't ignore the crime madrid did. we need justice judge!!! so far we can't do nothing.. :(

  16. ock19 says:

    "Justice" is a concept foreign to sport. Sorry samm.

    What we *really* need is to play well on the pitch, and win hardware. If we let Marca get us all riled up over nothing, they win– 'cause they've taken everybody's eye off the field of play, which is where we get to show, twice a year, that we're better than them no matter how much they spend.

Please, feel free to post your own comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.