Guardiola: Chess Master
On Saturday, April 10, 2010, Manuel Pelligrini, coach of Real Madrid, followed the same tactics as he had all season, using the formation and team (for the most part) that had achieved 15 straight victories in front of their home crowd and had scored the most goals in the league. They had not dropped a single point, so why change?
In the post-game program on GolTV, the announcer explained how Josep Guardiola, FC Barcelona head coach, proved to be the tactical master. While Pellegrini stayed with what had worked, Guardiola presented a lineup that had observers raising their eyebrows, with players shuffled out of their customary spots: with Messi as the lone striker, Alves on the right wing in the midfield, Pedro on the left, Xavi in the middle without Iniesta, and Puyol as right-back. This formation both strengthened the defense and the attack at the same time, considering that many of Messi’s goals have come via Alves.
For such an important game, it is a given that Pellegrini and his team would have studied previous Barcelona games to analyze their strengths and weaknesses. In his post-game comments, Guardiola made it quite clear that he had both understood and respected the threat Real Madrid presented, as well as their star player, Cristiano Ronaldo.
We tried to isolate him from the play, to control him a lot, because Cristiano is very dangerous when they have the ball. When we have the ball, that’s when he becomes very dangerous, because if we lose it, he finds it quickly and you can’t stop him. We talked a lot about the defense being very attentive to that.
Thus, when Barcelona took to the field, they were armed with a game-plan designed specifically for this match, one that provided for increased defense, yet remained true to their philosophy of ball possession and attacking football. They had prepared for the opposition’s 4-4-2 tactics with Ronaldo and Higuain up front as two dangerous strikers, and that is what they faced.
When Real Madrid took to the field, they found themselves face to face with a formation that matched none of the recordings of previous matches that they might have studied. One would assume that Pellegrini took notes during the first half to instruct his team on how to approach the game after the break. But Guardiola had that covered as well. In the second half, he switched Puyol from right to left defense, slotted Maxwell up to the midfield wing position, and slid Alves back to his customary right-back position.
The tactical genius of Guardiola, the Chess Master, is further revealed in an article published by Catalan news site Sport. According to the article, Pep approached the game with probably the same mental tactics as he had in other finals that Barcelona had faced. For this match, his words to his team, before they took to the field in the Santiago Bernabéu to confront Pellegrini’s ‘Galacticos’ and a stadium filled with 80,000 blancos supporters, were these:
I only ask three things of you: attack, attack, attack. Without rest, always attack. Relentlessly.
Earlier, Guardiola had left his players with another pearl of wisdom to help ease the pressure: “Whatever happens, we will continue forward because neither winning nor losing here decides the league.”
The team, nevertheless, started out a bit timid, gathering the lines and wanting to ensure they could withstand the pressure of their rivals. But little by little, they began to open up spaces, and the blaugrana machine began to engage all of its pieces. The goal by Messi, through a brilliant assistance by Xavi, was the just reward in a game that Pep had drawn a thousand and one times in his head.
At half time, Guardiola etched another phrase into the memories of his men: “Don’t make even one back-pass. Keep attacking.”
As if he were the Spartan general Leonidas in the battle of Thermopylae, Pep sought the complicity of his team at the moment of facing a rival that could have inflicted serious damage. Without a doubt, Guardiola fared better than Leonidas, who ended with an heroic defeat, as he and his team achieved a triumph that opens the path more clearly towards the championship of the league.
Finally, the article revealed one last detail. It is well known that Gerard Piqué is one of the big morale boosters in the blaugrana locker room. And he was the one who instigated the betting pool to see who could guess their rival for the Champions League quarter-finals (Alves and Messi won on that occasion). However, before El Clásico on Saturday, Guardiola prohibited any such initiative, to avoid anything that might add further pressure on the already heated match.
And thus, Josep Guardiola demonstrated once again that he is the blaugrana Chess Master.





























Great job BarcafanDallas, this is what i was waiting for, some one to writte about the new tactic that Pep used it over the weekend. I too was shocked to see the new format but i knew that Pep knows what he is doing and he always proves all the haters wrong.
Thanks again good stuff.
Thanks! I had recorded and finally watched at least part of the GolTV post-game show yesterday. They are the ones who explained how Pep was the chess master and how he made the choices to win the tactical battle. It made so much sense when I heard it, that I HAD to share!
I don't think Pep Guardiola has any haters left by this point.
Nice article, seems like gaurdiola was preparing for this match for a long time. i too was surprised by the formation and player setup but i guess pep showed why he is the coach and we are just fans. the thought of this guy after 5 years as a top division coach is scary. still has to improve on some areas but i can't deny he is close to being perfect.
Totally agree that Pep needs some improvements on some areas but get this though.. he is so far ahead of lots of Coaches , so he may not need that much of improvements. the only thing I some times don’t agree is the way he uses subs but he is the coach and i am only paying $90 to Goltv to watch lovely Barca..
Hey BarcaDallas… how about organizing a fan trip from USA to Camp nou I would be first to sign from Minnesota.
SIGH, oh if only! Maybe when the kids are grown and out of school.
im interested in such a trip as well…from washington dc
I am in for such a trip too.
Never trust the tv or other mainstream media for tactical analysis. All they resort to are generic statements which give you little or no information at all.
"This formation both strengthened the defense and the attack at the same time, considering that many of Messi’s goals have come via Alves."
Alves as RW did nothing to help the attack but provide an extra man in midfield. He is clearly at his most effective at RB from where he start his runs from deep and thus breaks through the defensive line.
What it did was help the defense by allowing Puyol to concentrate on helping Pique marshall Ronaldo. That flank was effectively nullified for both teams with little or nothing coming from it.
Real had just Gago and Alonso to cover Xavi, Keita and Messi everytime he dropped into midfield from his false 9 role. Madrid needed another player to pick up Xavi since Gago was pulled to the right (with Keita, Maxwell and Pedro operating from there). Xabi Alonso was not the man to do it, he never got close enough to Xavi.
The decision to start Alves at RW was perhaps the right one but not because he was effective as a winger. He just provided an extra man to outnumber the Madrid midfield and allowed the defenders to work as a more cohesive unit with RB Puyol no longer required in attack.
All things considered it was tactical genuis from Pep in putting out a more defensive formation from Barça but one that still allowed them to control midfield and possession while expending lesser energy. Sport's assertion that it is tactical genuis to say "Attack, attack, attack" is quite laughable.
dis is 1 way we can play teams like bayern manu chelsea sevila who can hurt us on the wings i think the inter game will be nice 2 av abidal n ibra n toure or even keiter 2 stop maicon
With Inter, the most important thing to work out will be how to get past their defense. Inter will try to hit us on the break through Sneijder, Milito and Eto'o.
The wings will be a major problem against Bayern who are one of the few teams remaining with 2 wingers. Most of the teams so far have had an unsymmetrical formation with attack primarily emanating from one flank.
Inter will be tougher to beat though .
Haha! that was just my interpretation (of Alves adding more offense), and I usually am very bad at tactics.
Your evaluation makes lots of sense. The main thing is that Pep effectively rearranged his team to shut down RM, as much as possible.
Exactly. At first I thought that Pep had made a grave tactical error, because Barcelona was somewhat impotent in attack (1 chance in the entire first half: the goal), because when Messi dropped back to help in the Midfield Xavi was left with few options to pass to in the final third. But as the big picture has come clearer, I think that that sacrificing offense for defense, nullifying Madrid's attack on both wings was the smart move.
"Alves as RW did nothing to help the attack but provide an extra man in midfield."
There is a difference between what Pep wants a player to do and what actually happens on the field. To say that he was there solely for the defensive contribution would be wrong.
Alves and Messi have a great understanding. As a result, when these two link it often results in a goal or a decent goal scoring opportunity at the least. As an example, I would list the back-heel flick Alves played for Messi against Stuttgart or the ball Alves played between 3 defenders in El Clasico at Camp Nou which released Messi one on one with Casillas. Unfortunately, he missed.
What can prevent Pep's idea to be materialized is the performance of our own player and the play of the opposition.
I believe "attack, attack, attack" is a consequence of the unfortunate translation rather than anything else. What he meant to say is "be aggressive, attack their players and space no matter where you find yourself on the field".
True, and that's what I was thinking with Alves in the MF. I by no means claim any tactical analysis ability, but it still makes sense, the way you say it.
As for the "attack, attack, attack," that is the quote presented by Sport (“Sólo os pido tres cosas: atacar, atacar y atacar. Sin descanso, atacar siempre. Sin tregua”. ) Now, it makes sense to me. Pep doesn't NEED to say more than that, because his team KNOWS what to do. They can read his mind.
If you have listened to Pep, he said something along the lines that Ronaldo is the most dangerous when we lose the possession. If that happens, it would be safe to say at that in most cases Alves would be far away from him at that specific moment and would have to hustle back. Since Alves is in very good physical shape, Pep was hoping he can achieve both tasks (offensively and defensively) with the equal success. The events on the field proved this to be just a bit out of reach for of our boy Dani.
Yeah, I didn't mean literary a bad translation since "atacar" is pretty clear. What I was trying to say is that it should be put into a context rather than to simplify it as an all-out attack which is the interpretation most people got.
Haha — yes! I think Dani was a bit confused by his role. There's a fun article here, where talks about seeing the board and thinking that he wasn't in the lineup.
http://www.sport.es/default.asp?idpublicacio_PK=4…
And I see what you're saying about the translation. Makes sense.
It was so funny, "Hola Pep, oh, I am not in the list? Oh I AM?" proceeds to be taken aback.. for 2 minutes.. :LOL
Are you implying that Pep assigned the Right Forward Dani Alves to mark Madrid's striker? Ludicrous !
If Alves's ability to link with Messi was the reason he was played at RW and I do not believe it was then that really fell flat. Barça's right flank was tied up with Alves, Puyol and further back Pique nullifying Arbeloa (who never tried to get forward), Marcelo and Ronaldo.
How many attacks originated from that flank ? If you didn't watch the game, try this on espn-soccernet, goto the match report and gamecast, select the attack chart option for Barça. It will show you that 49%of Barça's attacks were from the left, 26% centre and 25% from the right flank. And I am willing to bet that most of that 25% would have come in the 2nd half after the formation was changed.
Performance of the player ? Alves barely came into the game in an attacking sense while playing as RW.
Madrid had 16(7 on target) shots to Barça's 8(4 on target).
Barca had 2 goals and Madrid had 0. Pep wins
Yes. And finally, statistics don't tell the whole truth. For instance, Leo would have done hat-trick without Casillas' excellent blocks.
Barca were patient and made their shots count. That is all that matters!
Very misleading statistics.
Exactly. Interestingly enough, most of these came in the second half.
Out of those 7 Madrid had, Marcello practically passed the ball to Valdes, Gago had an attempt from 35 yards out, Guti had a lukewarm shot to the center of the goal, Ronaldo's free kick from 30 yards out.
Off the target, Higuain blasted the ball to the stands, Xabi Alonso shot it for the shooting sake, Xabi's header was offside, Higuain had a low shot which had a low probability of scoring to begin with, Benzema's header when everything was decided.
Meanwhile, all 4 of Barca shots were from the high-probability scoring opportunities. It speaks plenty that Pedro's was the worst one.
My point was to indicate that it wasn't all out attack from Barça. We dominated the game in a totally different way.
God bless America! =) or whatever…..thank you BarcaFanDallas! That is really something you cannot get in this little shithead hockey land named Finland. In this country you merely see the results written in newspapers. I cannot enough express my gratitude for your work. Keep going!
"Pep, praised to the skies." If possible, write few words about this headline. THX!
i also join the plead, translate , please…
btw – for kontiki- the key against inter will be their defending style. if they repeat the same stubborn purely zonal model- we might even crush them. but, i do agree we will have to keep watching over their counters…
Link? I don't see an article with that headline on EMD. is it this one: http://www.elmundodeportivo.es/gen/20100412/53904…
I can work on it.
i will say, after watching the post-game press conference, which was on GolTV, Pep was soooo funny to watch. He was busting with energy, obviously wanting to get out of there. He was constantly moving around and at one point looked at his watch. I'm sure he want to get back to the celebration!
Sorry. I can't help. That headline was in the front of El Mundo Deportivo (presented in the front page of this site).
http://www.totalbarca.com/2010/news/the-front-el-…
Yes, it's the same — it's an article about how the celebration continued in the dressing room – Pep was praised by his players and was on Cloud 9.
It's still a good article. It's good to see the boys do happy! And then we all can trust Pep to plant their feet firmly on the ground today to prepare for Wednesday's game.
Thanks. . . . can't wait for Wed's game to see our praised and well respected team again.
Fast and dirty translation of that article:
"The victory huddle on Bernabeau’s pitch with which Barça players celebrated their overwhelming triumph over Madrid continued in the locker room. Once inside, all members of the team got together in another victory circle and with the simple football war cry of “oeee oe oe oeee, oeee, oeeeee” they worked out all of the adrenaline left in their bodies after another emotional night.
Everybody was happy, but the canteranos were the most euphoric. Xavi, who had a brilliant match, was exultant, just like Piqué, Puyol, Busquets, Valdes, Iniesta or Pedro, who was congratulated most of all for managing to cap off, in absolute humility, his glorious year: now he only has to score in the semis and final of the Champions League. Messi was brimming with happiness, but in his manner, quietly, without making a fuss. A whole other story could be written about Milito, who was heavily motivated by some unfortunate comments made by Valdano when he was injured, and Guardiola, the leader of the group. Pep, cule through and through, couldn’t totally assimilate an amazing statistic that more than one person told him about: that he was the only person to ever beat Madrid four times in a row. That was why he was walking on clouds.
But of course, after he left the locker room on the way to the press conference, he planted his feet firmly back on the ground and reminded us, as is his way, that “this victory only matters if we win La Liga”. By the way, the next day was special for Xavi and Marquez. They took advantage of the day off to spend time with their families in Madrid. "
Yes, thanks!
Thank you….and the next Marca reports that they are shot in the streets…..(bad joke).
no, i think i saw it on the front page as a title either of sport or el mundo, i'm not sure…
The headline on the front of Mundo Dep referred to their "top secret" report, which was about the celebration in the locker room ("Pep esta' en un nube). That is the same article that fcbarcatenerofe translated. Let me know if you find any links to anything else.
but, thanks a lot in any case
to be honest i wasnt that surprised by guardiolas lineup.. i was expecting him to do something different as he has in almost all our crucial games (think champions leauge and copa finals)
although i do admit i was never expecting to see alves as RF.. though i doubt anyone except guardiola himself did.. alves was probly pretty shocked too
Maggie, nice article to complement my opinion piece that is coming out real soon. This is not the first time Pep has done his tactical genius, and I wouldn't bet on it being the last.
Visca Barca!
I've got to admit, when I first saw the lineup I was so confused. But after a few minutes into the game I realized how smart it was. We might have lacked a bit of firepower, but we made sure that we had the defense secure by adding an extra midfielder to get the ball as fast as possible (Alves was at RW but helped alot defensively). I also noticed that at some points it seemed like Xavi was in that #10 role just behind Messi, while Pedro and Alves stayed pretty close to their wings. I think this helped Messi know that he wouldn't have to drop back so much, as he wouldn't have to play that "link" role that Xavi had covered.
Here's another version of what a writer saw while at the game. It's a fun read: http://soccernet.espn.go.com/columns/story?id=769…
yeah read this before, nice one kinda emo but cool nonetheless. good write up maggie.
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Monica Ramirez. Monica Ramirez said: Guardiola: Chess Master http://bit.ly/8ZaMIe [...]