Cruyff’s Corner: Messi’s contract is exaggerated
This is a featured article. Please scroll down, for all the latest on FC Barcelona.
Johan Cruyff writes a weekly column in Spanish newspaper, El Periodico. In this edition, Cruyff analyses the extension of Lionel Messi’s contract. You can find the piece after the jump.
THE CONTRACT OF LIONEL MESSI
Messi extended his contract some weeks ago with an improved salary. With his skills, accomplishments and effort, individually and collectively, there is nothing you can say against his contract. Extension of his contract till 2016 is something completely different. Personally, I prefer short contracts over long ones, and by short contracts I mean 3 or 4 years. To me that rule goes for everybody, including the best player in the world, no matter who he is.
Irrespective of who the player is, he needs motivation to be able to grow. As a club I would rather give him the possibility to improve year after year, if he has earned the improvement. Because when it comes to sporting matters you can never be too careful. I know very well that his buyout clause is an anti Florentino clause, which also equals his contract with the best in the world, without bonus. But Barcelona over-did it with the extension till 2016. I don’t say this for the clubs sake, but for the player’s. The club did it because of the age old fear of bogeymen appearing and taking him away. But so what if they came? There are plenty of such bogeymen in football and yes….they can and will appear.
The boy deserves his contract like no one else, no doubts about it. But I would have used another way. And not only for him, for the rest of them as well. Three years contract or a maximum of four, and for each year that goes, you can add another in the contract. The extra year method would be more expensive if the player does well, than if he signs till 2016. But I prefer this solution, even if it means the bogeymen show up and cause problems.

Performance
To me it’s not a question of paying him 8, 10 or 12 million Euro. The real question is to find a way to reward the actual performance, not paying him on the basis of your calculations on how he could perform, especially over such a long time. And this is the way which, I insist, is good for the club, and even better for the player. The difference between playing well and exceptionally well is not that big. The difference between performing exceptionally well individually and not that well collectively is not that big either. And football is a team sport. The difference can come from whether you are 100 % concentrated or 90 %.
Will the year be good to him? And a good year is not an exceptional year. Give him one year’s extension, and raise his salary. I would happily pay him more than I would have paid him with a longer contract, but I’d still prefer to pay him thus, since in this way he proves one thing: that you perform at a maximum level, year after year. This is not done for nothing. Look at previous examples; a lot of big names, great players, have signed long contracts, and have later performed poorer than they did on the day they signed. Long contracts fail with 9 out of 10 players. And therefore, I have serious doubts about this move helping players perform better.
Basically, it’s about changing something to motivate performance. Like Guardiola did in another instance by replacing Eto’o with Ibrahimovic in the squad. I’m glad to see that they have stopped the comparisons between them after a couple of rounds in the league.
In Guardiola’s position
For starters, and unlike three years ago after the Champions League final in Paris, they found out that something had to be done, something important, something shocking, to end the recognition, no matter how good it was. I put myself in Guardiola’s position and found the best means at my disposal: Messi, Xavi, Iniesta and Eto’o….Who do I choose to shake up the squad? Who should I replace? I know what I want; that the performance doesn’t drop, and that there comes in a new challenge that they can work with. And I want this by replacing one player. A player, who by virtue of his different quality, involves the full attention of the rest. Xavi and Iniesta are indispensable cogs in the Barca machinery. Messi is different than everyone else. Therefore the decision is clear. In addition; Eto’o was the only with a contract that was about to expire. And by being number 9, the rest of the team will always depend on the movements from this key player. Only one change, but a good one nonetheless.
First major duel
Some observations about Sevilla vs Real Madrid:
The Andalucians play somewhat like Barca. They use their flanks with Navas, Perotti and Capel. They make the pitch big and allow the midfielders to come in the zone of the last 3/4 part of the pitch. When it comes to this, Barcelona, Sevilla and Real Madrid are quite similar: they like to play 15-20 yards from goal and that is synonymous with show business. Direct game and victory for the most successful. Like Sevilla yesterday (in the 4-1 away victory over Glasgow Rangers in the CL). Can they fight for the league? Yes, but they will have problems with the smaller teams. Therefore I believe they will do it better in Champions League. And Real Madrid? They proved that they are difficult to beat. And they showed their attitude. Ramos could be an influence on final play.





























Nice article. Cruyff is quite smart.
He has a very intelligent football mind.
I agree a lot with Cruyff but he has to know that Messi is an exception to the rule.
I don't believe Messi, Xavi, Iniesta, Puyol, or anyone is an exception. I truly believe what Cruyff said. I don't think you need to tie a player to his club for 6 years!!!! That's practically almost half the footballer's professional life in his prime. You need to give the player a motivation. You do that year by year. If the player performs and/or stays/starts his prime reward him with a salary increase and add a year, maybe include some bonuses. If the player drops level, performs poorly, or has an excess of injuries then don't punish him but instead don't reward him. He will see the others get raises or whatever and would want to try harder. Now you also can't judge a player's performance by one or two games, he needs to perform game by game. There are perfect examples in this club and team.
Also you can't use Florentino's power to influence this kind of action. Do you really think Messi will want to go to Madrid or any other club for that matter? Manchester City have already tried by offering the buyout clause and an incredible salary, where did Messi end up?? Barcelona.
I also agree how Cruyff talks about team motivation. How getting rid of an important role that Eto'o had will give players motivation. Barca right now has 1. WCC, 2. repeat of Champions, 3. Florentino's Galactico conquest, and 4. repeat of Treble for motivation. But what happens if Barca achieve it??? What motivation will the players have???
Cruyff is a genius.
love this blog…way to go!!!
!! mes que un club !!
I agree bec messi is commited so we shouldnt sign him for 6 years thats too long but I am sure if he continues his form he will be renewed every 2_3 years so lets see
cruyff is very clever and using examples perfectly and you can see why laporta practically begged cruyff to take the job as barca coach if guardiola said no, i agree with cruyff for these reasons.
the player stays motivated by a short deal to 2014 was fine simple raise the wages slighly and the buy out clause, secondly messi leaving is solely on how messi feels to date messi has always been truthful with his statements about wanting to stay for the rest of his career and he will stay for as long as the club wants him or when he feels he wants a new challenge really the club should not worry about vultures like perez or man city as messi would not even give it consideration and if the day comes leo does leave barca have a healthy €250m clause to fall back on!!
nah, cruyff's just jealous!
Cruyff ain't jealous, Im pretty sure
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by totalBarca and Danish Arif. Danish Arif said: totalBarca featured article: Cruyff’s Corner: Messi’s contract is exaggerated – http://bit.ly/17f1bw [...]
thanks for the atricle…the blog is awsome!!!
plus I agree with Cruyff
Great article
Although I already read the Dutch version =P
i love this guy, when i first say the Caption on goal.com, i was a bit furious but after reading it i began to realise that he has spoken real sense.No offense to Eto'o as well since his comments on that is also exactly what i've been thinking but for now let's hope that NONE of the players gets swollen headed.Then we can obtain results, for MADrid, i hope they place third this season.AMEN
What do you expect, it was on goal.com!
Tonight, i can't imagine that i'm by your sidee…cos its never gonna be the truth, so FARRR for Youuu
I respect cryuff’s commemts.But i feel messi deserves it.We dont want another figo moreover fabregas signed 8yr extension few years ago with arse nal